5 Best Cheese For Cold Sandwiches

(Last Updated On: June 19, 2022)
As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases

Olivia loves to do cooking experiments. Last night, she made a cold sandwich and added some leftover cheese. She found it interesting and then used several kinds of cheese in cold sandwich. After using and tasting different types of cheese, she found some of them really go well with the cold sandwich. 

If you are a cheese sandwich lover, then adding a little bit of cheese with a sandwich is a must. But which cheese is the best for cold sandwiches? All cheeses are not suitable for cold sandwiches as their making procedure and ingredients are slightly different from regular sandwiches. 

Well, if you don’t have any idea, this article is for you. Here we are going to introduce the 5 best cheese for cold sandwiches that you will definitely love.  

Image Product Price Weight Rating
Kraft-Singles-American-Cheese-Slices-1 Kraft Singles American Cheese Slices

CHECK PRICE 1 pound 4.9/5.0
igourmet-English-Blue-Stilton-Cheese-DOP-by-Tuxford-and-Tebbutt igourmet English Blue Stilton Cheese CHECK PRICE 2.5 Pounds 4.9/5.0
Philadelphia-Cream-Cheese-Brick Philadelphia Cream Cheese Brick CHECK PRICE 8.0 oz 4.8/5.0
Sargento-Sliced-Pepper-Jack-Cheese Sargento, Sliced Pepper Jack Cheese CHECK PRICE 7.5 oz 4.8/5.0
Amazon-Brand-Happy-Belly-Shredded-Low-Moisture-Part-Skim-Mozzarella-Cheese Amazon Brand – Happy Belly Shredded Low-Moisture, Part-Skim Mozzarella Cheese CHECK PRICE 16 ounce 4.8/5.0

Why Do You Need Special Cheese For Cold Sandwiches? 

A cold sandwich is a combination of cold toppings like meat, sometimes fish, and grilled vegetables, fresh basil, green pepper/ bell pepper, green lettuce, etc between 2 sliced pieces of white bread. Using a little bit of cheese in a cold sandwich adds luxury to it. But all kinds of cheeses are not suitable for cold sandwiches.

Mostly, the American cheese, Pepper jack cheese, part-Skim Mozzarella Cheese, blue cheese,  swiss cheese, cream cheese, etc are appropriate for a cold sandwich. They are low moist and dry cheese. So you will get the real taste of the sandwich. 

Why Do You Need Special Cheese For Cold Sandwiches

As the toppings are cold, you have to be careful about selecting cheese for the sandwich. Some of them are highly moist and remain hard at the cold stage. So, you can’t eat them properly before melting. 

Again, the mentioned cheeses are the great source of protein, fat, and calcium. Also, contain vitamin A and B-12.

Here we have picked the 5 best cheeses for cold sandwiches. So you can choose any of them or combine them in the cold sandwich to enhance taste 100 times better. 

The Best Cheese For Cold Sandwiches | Top 5

Kraft Singles American Cheese Slices (24 Slices, 1 pound)


Milk, Whey, Milk Protein Concentrate, , Whey Protein Concentrate, Salt, Cheese Culture, Milkfat, Sodium Citrate, contains less than 2% of Calcium Phosphate, Annatto and Paprika (color), Lactic Acid, Sorbic Acid as a preservative Enzymes, Vitamin D3

In-depth review  

First, we have chosen the Kraft Singles American cheese which comes in 1 pound packaging. Also, they are pre-sliced so that you don’t need to slice them for use in the sandwich. The Kraft Singles American cheese is made from quality milk which contains protein, vitamins, and fat. Also free from any artificial color, aroma, and preservatives. 

You can easily serve your kid too without any health risk. Also, the smooth texture creates a great combination with all other toppings. The mild and creamy consistency simply melts your heart at every bite. 

Additionally, you can store them in the refrigerator. It will remain fresh and tasty for a long time.

So far, you can use this American cheese on any kind of fast foods like burger, pizza, and summer grilling food items. 

igourmet English Blue Stilton Cheese DOP by Tuxford and Tebbutt – 2.5 Half Moon Cut (2.5 pounds)

igourmet English Blue Stilton Cheese DOP by Tuxford and Tebbutt

In-depth review  

Our next pick is Blue Stilton cheese from igourmet. It’s a family-size cheese that contains 2 Pounds. You can eat them for a long time as cold sandwich toppings, or use in other snacks and fast food items.  

igourmet English Blue Stilton Cheese is made of milk with rich flavor and a piquant finish. For the flavor, consistency, and smooth texture, it is also known as the “ king of cheese”. 

At the same time, it is made by maintaining all quality standards. Your whole family can eat without any adverse effects on health. 

It comes in raw so you can use slicers or graters based on your preferences. In which way you add igourmet English Blue Stilton Cheese in the cold sandwich, it will increase the taste surely.

Philadelphia Cream Cheese Brick (8 oz Boxes, Pack of 2)

Philadelphia Cream Cheese Brick

In-depth review  

Our next pick is Philadelphia Cream Cheese which is made with real cream and fresh milk. With the nutrition facts of milk and cream, there are no extra preservatives or harmful chemicals. Also, you will get 100 calories per serving. Hence, to fulfill the lack of protein, you can go for this cream cheese without any hesitation. 

Using cold toppings with cream cheese makes the cold sandwich more delicious and mouth-watering. If you like spice, you can spread some black pepper on the toppings. Also, you don’t have to worry about any health risks. 

Again, you can keep it in the refrigerator for storing purposes. The cream cheese will remain flavorful and fresh for a long period. 

For the smooth and mild texture, you can use the Philadelphia Cream Cheese for making cheesecakes as well. It’s a low moist cheese which you can use on any type of food item you want. 

Sargento Sliced Pepper Jack Cheese, 7.5 oz

Sargento, Sliced Pepper Jack Cheese

In-depth review  

If you prefer spice in your favorite sandwich, Sargento Sliced Pepper Jack Cheese can be the best option for you.

Sargento Sliced Pepper Jack Cheese comes in 7.5 oz packaging. If you have no time on a busy morning, you can make a cold sandwich using a slice of pepper jack cheese. That will reduce the hassle of slicing the cheese. Just open the packet, and they are ready to eat.

Moreover, Sargento Sliced Pepper Jack Cheese is made by natural ingredients like hot peppers, milk, salt, natural enzymes, cheese culture, etc. There are no artificial flavors or chemicals used. 

Again the packing is so convenient to use. You can easily open and close them. For storing purposes, keep items in the refrigerator. As the quantity is little, try to eat them within 5 to 10 days to get the real taste and flavor of Jack cheese.

Amazon Brand – Happy Belly Shredded Low-Moisture, Part-Skim Mozzarella Cheese, 16 ounce

Amazon Brand - Happy Belly Shredded Low-Moisture, Part-Skim Mozzarella Cheese,

In-depth review  

Our last pick is for those who love part skim Mozzarella cheese too much. So we are going to introduce the Amazon Brand – Happy Belly Shredded Part-Skim Mozzarella Cheese. It’s a low moist cheese.

We already mentioned that low moist cheeses are the best for a cold sandwich. That will melt down so easily with the cold toppings. Also as they are pre-grated, you don’t need to use a cheese grater.  Just open the packet and add on the sandwich.

The quantity of Happy Belly Mozzarella Cheese is 16 ounces which is a decent amount to make several sandwiches. Also, you can store the leftovers in the fridge. That will remain fresh like the opening time. 

So far, Happy Belly Mozzarella Cheese is made with fresh milk. That will help to fulfill the lack of calcium, protein, and fat. You can eat this cheese with other food items like burgers, pizza, pasta as well. 

So add a little bit of Happy Belly Shredded Low-Moisture, part-Skim Mozzarella Cheese to increase the taste of the cold sandwich far better than any renowned restaurant.  

Final verdict

Making a cold sandwich isn’t hard. But if you choose the wrong cheese, that will surely be a mess. Moreover, adding appropriate cheese will enhance the taste more whether you choose a meat or vegetarian sandwich. Hopefully, now you can choose the right cheese for making a cold sandwich if you have confusion before. 

Our 5 picks are healthy, chemical, and preservative-free. Also made by maintaining quality standards.  Also, they are versatile so you can use them on other food items. There is no change of wastage as well.

Feel free to comment below if you want sandwich recipes or inbox us for any recommendations, suggestions, or quereis. 

Eat healthily, stay healthy.

Leave a Comment