Best Oil for Mayonnaise | Top – 8

(Last Updated On: )
As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases

Are you looking for the best oil for mayonnaise? Choosing the best oil for mayonnaise can be a daunting task. It is essential to find an oil that will give the desired consistency and flavor to your mayonnaise while being compatible with the other ingredients used in the recipe. You can use many different oils in mayonnaise, but which is the best?

This article will guide you in finding the best oil for making mayonnaise that has pronounced flavor and makes your mayonnaise super mouth-watering.

What Does Oil Do in Mayonnaise?

Mayonnaise is a lot like men, it can make everything much better, adding flavor and ease to your life. Or, it can just be sticky and gross and make you nauseous”

Sarah Dessen

Mayonnaise is a creamy, thick, and delicious sauce in which oil, egg yolk, vinegar/ lemon juice, and seasonings are the main ingredients. Now, what does oil do in mayonnaise?

Well, mayonnaise is an emulsion of oil and water of egg yolk and other ingredients. When two liquids are not combined naturally, like oil and water, they will make a suspension if you blend them.

What does oil do in mayonnaise

Add a few drops of oil to the mixture and blend briefly to make mayonnaise. The oil will break down into super-small droplets and create suspense with the watery part of other ingredients, especially egg whites, and yolk. Again, add some drops of oil and blend until they make a consistent and even mixture. In such a way, the mayonnaise becomes thickened and tastes delicious!

8 Best Oils for Mayonnaise of 2023

This post will review the eight best oils for mayonnaise from 4 oils: avocado, peanut, sunflower, and canola oil. Two oils from each type have been selected and reviewed with their advantages and disadvantages. 

So, let’s jump into the review section of the best oil for mayonnaise.

Avocado Oil

Two avocado oils have been selected to review as the best for mayonnaise because it is one of the safest and healthiest oils. It contains several essential nutrients like potassium, vitamins C, E, and K. They all take part in protecting your overall health. It controls blood sugar and cholesterol, keeps the heart healthy, and helps to digest. Also, it is pregnancy safe.

This oil has a natural taste and flavor and is perfect for making salad dressing, mayo sauce, marinating, etc. This oil is usually for regular cooking, baking, and deep frying

Chosen Foods 100% Pure Avocado Oil -2 Liter

Chosen Foods 100% Pure Avocado Oil

The first product of the best oil for mayonnaise is Chosen Foods 100% Pure Avocado Oil. This is specially made for making homemade sauces like mayonnaise, salad dressing, marinades, baking, cooking, and frying. The brand claims they are 100% organic and processed by non-GMO techniques. It also contains vitamins C, E, K, potassium, and folate.

You can cook at high heat; the smoke point is up to 500°F. And the regular blender or whisk temperature won’t cross that much heat while making mayonnaise. As this oil is safe to eat raw or in dressing and sauces, you can use it without any doubt. 

It comes in 2 liters, enough to make plenty of mayonnaise. Again the packaging is compact, eco-friendly, and convenient to use. At the same time, it is easy to pour and add tiny drops into the mayo mix bowl.

Add a few drops of avocado oil and blend continuously for a while. Then add oil drops again and mix until the mixture thickens.

Organic avocado oil increases the taste of homemade mayonnaise ten times more than any other cooking oil and has no artificial aroma or harmful chemicals.

Once you start using avocado oil to make mayonnaise and see its performance, you won’t look behind or need to search for any other oil.

  • Specially produced for making mayonnaise, dressing, and marinating
  • 100% organic, non-GMO processed oil
  • Safe and healthy for the heart, body, and mind
  • High-heat cooking capability
  • Natural aroma enhances the taste of mayonnaise
  • Up to 500 degrees Fahrenheit smoking point.
  • BPA-free, eco-friendly, and safe Packaging
  • Do not use more than ten drops at once in mayo mix, or you may face uneven mixing problems.

100% Pure Nutiva Organic Steam-Refined Avocado Oil, 24 Fl Oz Glass 

100% Pure Nutiva Organic Steam-Refined Avocado Oil

This is a 100% pure avocado oil processed by steam-refined technique. Pure Nutiva Organic Steam-Refined Avocado Oil comes in 24 ounces, the perfect size for occasionally making mayonnaise. There is no alternative to avocado oil to make perfectly thick and delicious mayo sauce. 

This non-GMO oil has no artificial aroma or chemicals. So if you are health conscious and smell sensitive at the same time, Nutiva Organic Steam-Refined Avocado Oil is a good option for you.

Its organic and neutral flavor won’t change the authentic taste of mayonnaise but rather help increase the taste by removing the egg yolk flavor. No pre-melting is needed. Just make sure other ingredients are at room temperature.

Like the previous products, this oil is enriched with vitamins K, C, and E, potassium, and folate. When making mayonnaise, the oil won’t be cooked. It just blends at a specific speed and temperature for a short period. Avocado oil is a really healthy option when making mayonnaise.

Nutiva Organic avocado oil is 100% pure in nature and can satisfy customers through its performance. In addition to making mayonnaise, using avocado oil for cooking or frying food items can be a healthy choice.

  • Perfect size for making mayonnaise occasionally. 
  • Natural aroma enhances the taste of mayo
  • 100% pure, the world’s finest fresh, organic avocado oil is healthy and safe to eat
  • No need to worry about blending temperature for higher smoke points around 500°F
  • Non-GMO, steam-refined, and USDA certified
  • It contains vitamins K, C, and E, folate, potassium,
  • Eco-friendly, BPA-free, and compact Packaging
  • It won’t mix properly with egg whites, yolk, and other ingredients if it is below or above room temperature.

Peanut Oil

Peanut oil is a good option for cooking, baking, or making homemade sauce like mayonnaise. This type of oil can be processed in 3 ways such as refined, cold-pressed, and gourmet techniques. But the healthiest variety is to purchase a cold press. In the cold-pressed technic, they are slowly crushed to release their oil in a low heat temperature that ensures more nutrition, like Vitamin E, which protects from free radicals.

Peanut oil keeps the heart well and controls the blood sugar getting so high. It also improves good cholesterol.

The only downside is that peanut oil contains Omega 6 fatty acids that may cause inflammation in the body when the oil is cooked.

Now, these two peanut oils are best for making delicious and perfect mayonnaise, cooking, and deep-frying. Also, both are free from Omega 6 fatty acids and trans fat.

Amazon Brand – Happy Belly Peanut Oil, 128 Fl Oz

Amazon Brand - Happy Belly Peanut Oil

You must mix 3-4 cups of oil for one large yolk to make tasty and delicious mayonnaise. Mayonnaise sauce contains almost 70% oil, with the other 30% being a range of ingredients. One option to review the best oil for mayonnaise is this Amazon Brand – Happy Belly Peanut Oil, which comes with 128 Fl Oz in a bottle.

This peanut oil will be a healthy option for making tasty mayonnaise. It comes in large quantities at an affordable price, and the oil is free from any die, color, chemicals, or flavor. 

Also, the oil comes with 0g of cholesterol and trans fat, so it’s a healthier option.

The Amazon brand is confident about customer satisfaction by using its oil and offers a refund if you aren’t satisfied within a year of purchase.

  • It comes in a huge quantity of 1 gallon.
  • Convenient to use for any cooking and fried items
  • No trans fat, fragrance, and cholesterol
  • Healthy and great for making perfect mayonnaise
  • Good packaging and large size at a reasonable price range
  • Some customers argue the oil does not have a peanut smell.

Snappy Popcorn 1 Gallon Snappy Pure Peanut Oil- 128 Fl Oz

Snappy Popcorn 1 Gallon Snappy Pure Peanut Oil

Next is Snappy Pure Peanut Oil, a great and healthy ingredient for mayonnaise.

First, peanut oil is a healthy option for any cooking. As it is impossible to skip adding oil to mayonnaise, you should choose an oil that does not harm your health. Therefore, the peanut is suitable as a raw salad dressing or for making mayonnaise.  

Snappy’s Pure Peanut oil is natural and has a slightly nutty scent. Also, it is produced by cold-pressed technology so that it won’t separate the mayonnaise sauce. You don’t have to wait for melting as that oil is pourable at room temperature.

In addition, Snappy’s Pure Peanut oil is free from any artificial colors or chemicals. You don’t have to worry about side effects or weight gain as trans fat and cholesterol are absent in this oil.

The oil-in-water emulsion happens when you make mayonnaise. The oil and water of egg yolk create a suspension for whisking continuously, and you will get a great mixture of mayonnaise.

So far, it’s a versatile oil you can also use for making popcorn or any fried food.

  • Can make a thick and delicious mayonnaise
  • Enriched with nutty flavor and taste, which won’t make any difference in the real taste of mayonnaise
  • Free from artificial color, chemicals
  • Zero cholesterol and trans fat
  • Pourable without the additional melting requirement 
  • Featured with excellent high-heat stability
  • Versatile oil that you can use for any cooking along with mayonnaise
  • If you are smell sensitive, you must face a problem while pouring for a little nutty flavor and taste. However, the nutty flavor and taste will vanish after whisking for a while and won’t change the real taste of mayonnaise.

Sunflower Oil

Another healthy and safe oil to make tasty, creamy mayo is sunflower oil. Healthy, light, and golden sunflower oil contains more vitamin E, a natural antioxidant, and low saturated fat than other vegetable oils. Even the American Health Association has listed sunflower oil as one of the healthiest oils as it has a small amount of saturated fat.

You can use sunflower oil for high-heat cooking and frying, as it has a high smoke point. It can be used as an alternative to butter when frying. Sunflower oil can add a subtle taste to your mayonnaise.

Healthy Harvest Non-GMO Sunflower Oil – 1 gallon

Healthy Harvest Non-GMO Sunflower Oil

The combination of sunflower oil and egg yolk can make a huge volume by whisking continuously. As a mayonnaise lover, you can go for Healthy Harvest Non-GMO Sunflower Oil to make thick and delicious mayonnaise!

Healthy Harvest Non-GMO Sunflower Oil is free from harsh chemicals, hydrogenation, or other damaging processing. The oil is fully processed by non-GMO technic and physical refining methods to enrich natural antioxidants, Vitamin E, and inherent, Omega-3 fatty acids.

This choice is natural sunflower oil, a healthy option for making tasty mayonnaise! In addition, you can cook or fry any food items with this oil.

  • Fully natural, non-GMO processed sunflower oil
  • A high smoke point of about 450 degrees
  • Can make a delicious, super thick mayonnaise
  • Contains no chemical or other harsh ingredients
  • Increase mayonnaise’s flavor and shelf time
  • Containing natural antioxidants and vitamin E can help to digest 
  • Helpful to reduce cholesterol over other oils
  • Adding too much oil may cause a stretch of the stomach. Also, ensure your blender’s heat does not exceed the smoke point.

Native Harvest Non-GMO Sunflower Oil – 1 Litre (33.8 FL OZ)

If you are looking for a smaller-size sunflower oil bottle, Native Harvest Organic Sunflower Oil is a good choice. It comes in a 1-liter bottle.

This oil is organically manufactured and not only for making mayonnaise but is also suitable for any cooking, frying, and even making salad dressing.

Native Harvest Organic Sunflower Oil is refined at high heat. It also offers to cook at a high temperature, ensuring excellent stability. The mixture remains the same, full of taste and flavor for a long time.

After making mayonnaise with this oil, it won’t freeze or do not leave water on the mixture.

If you like to make mayonnaise on an occasional basis with sunflower oil, you do not need a 1-gallon oil pot. To consider this situation, this sunflower oil has been reviewed as one of the best oils for mayonnaise.

  • Organic sunflower oil doesn’t learn any side effects on health.
  • It can make great suspense with egg yolk and thick-volume mayonnaise.
  • Do not require pre-melting 
  • It contains antioxidants and vitamin E
  • Compact size and versatile usability 
  • This oil will only be able to create an even and consistent mixture of mayonnaise if other ingredients are at room temperature.

Canola Oil

The next healthy and best oil for mayonnaise is canola oil. Canola oil protects cell membranes throughout the body with its vitamin E and natural antioxidants. Vitamin E is also good for the skin and eradicates acne, wrinkles, fine lines, etc. Canola oil contains less saturated fat, which helps to protect your heart. Again, it can control cholesterol absorption from other food sources.

Eating raw or in mayonnaise and salad dressing is suitable, along with cooking, baking, and frying.

Healthy Harvest Canola Oil -One Gallon/128 oz

Healthy Harvest Canola Oil

If you like to buy canola oil as the main ingredient of mayonnaise, you can go for Healthy Harvest Canola Oil.

Healthy Harvest Canola Oil is a non-GMO oil that is safe for cooking or eating with either salad or mayo. You can use it directly on mayonnaise as it does not require pre-melting. 

Whatever amount you use on mayonnaise or cooking, oil should be organic. This canola oil contains natural antioxidants that are healthy ingredients to fight various diseases. Besides, it has Omega 3 fatty acids that are helpful to boost your energy level. Canola oil is the best option for you if you have a gastric or digestive problem.

If you are a mayo lover or your kids need every afternoon snack with mayo, this oil can be your best choice. You can add some drops of almond oil, which will make your mayo will get more thick and more delicious. 

This oil comes with amazing packaging in the size of 1 gallon. And they ensure it will remain fresh at the last drop of oil. 

  • Fully organic and non-GMO oil
  • Able to generate thick, delicious mayonnaise
  • Enrich with natural anti-oxidant and Omega 3 fatty acids
  • Pretty large size to use for a long time 
  • High smoking point, so there is no need to worry about your blender’s temperature
  • Adding too much oil may cause a split right away. As the bottle size is 1 gallon, you can pour in a little one or spray bottle to add it to the mayo mix.

365 by Whole Foods Market, Spray Canola Oil, 5 Fl Oz

365 by Whole Foods Market

While making mayonnaise, you should add a tiny amount of oil; otherwise, the mixture may split right away. Sometimes it’s hard to add small drops to the bowl. So here is a review of a spray system canola oil of 365 by Whole Foods Market

365 by Whole Foods Market canola oil is expeller-pressed, meaning they do not use chemicals but physically squeeze the seed to get the oil out. 

The smoke point is quite high, at approximately 450 degrees Fahrenheit. This means there’s little chance of generating smoke when blending the mayo mix.

At first, you just spray for once to incorporate the oil and other ingredients. Then blend for a while and again spray oil on it. By spraying oil and blending, the mayo will get thicker slowly. In addition, there is no chance of oil wastage.

As organic canola oil is a healthy choice for cooking and frying, you can use it for making mayo or dressing. The size is also travel-friendly and affordable in price.

  • Organic and expeller-pressed oil 
  • A non-GMO product and Free from chemicals
  • Does not their high-quality nutrients after cooking
  • The spray system is convenient to use
  • Has a high range of smoke point 
  • No adverse effect on health
  • The size is quite small so that you have to refile after several usages

Best Oil Combination for Homemade Mayonnaise Recipe?

In this article, 4 types of oils such as avocado, peanut, sunflower, and canola oil, are shown to be the best for making creamy, thick, and perfect mayonnaise. If you want, you can create a combination of any type of oil and use it in mayonnaise. Ensure the oil combo and other ingredients are at the same room temperature. If not, wait to release or gain heat to come at the same temperature. The oil will make a great suspension with the same temperature egg yolk.

You can use grapeseed oil as well. It is not recommended to use extra virgin olive or regular olive oil when making mayo from scratch as it may cause a bitter taste and sometimes a pungent smell. Then you must use fresh lemon juice or apple cider vinegar to balance the taste and strong flavor.

Final Verdict 

A good amount of oil is needed to thicken mayonnaise, which may not have good implications for your health. To avoid any kinds of health risks, you should use organic, pure, and non-GMO oil to make different kinds of mayonnaise. The perfection and taste almost depend on the oil, so you must choose the best one considering your and your family’s health protection. A good oil also increases the shelf-life of your mayonnaise.

You should also use organic oil for cooking, baking, or salad dressing. Avocado, peanut, sunflower, and canola oil are the best oils for mayonnaise and cooking regular food items. This post has reviewed 8 oils based on their quality, size, price range, and processed technique.

Leave a Comment