Best sauce for Philly cheesesteak

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases

My grandmother’s hand-made Philly cheesesteak is super tasty. Like me, my daughter Marena likes steak very much. I asked my grandmother what the secret was!

He said that the perfect combination of suitable sauces, thinly sliced rib-eye steak with soft bread can make a delicious Philly cheesesteak sandwich.

But which is the best sauce for Philly cheesesteak? You can use cheese sauce, steak sauce, tomato sauce, or even cocktail sauce. Or you can use a mixture of them. Depending on the combination of steak and sauces, the Philly cheesesteak will be tastier, flavorful, and juicy.

Back home and search one by one to find out the best sauce from each category. That’s why today we are going to share the best sauces for Philly cheesesteak.

Why do you need special sauce for Philly cheesesteak?

Why do you need special sauce for Philly cheesesteak? Why can’t we use any kind of sauce to make Philly cheesesteak? Philly cheesesteak is a type of sandwich also known as Philadelphia cheesesteak which was invented by Philadelphians Pat and Harry Olivieri. It uses a mixture of ground or thinly sliced ribeye steak, caramelized onions, melty cheese inside a long hoagie roll. And it just takes 2-4 minutes to make.

Gradually it was made with a combination of more sauces. But not all sauces work well as ingredients. Experiments have shown that some sauces, such as cheese sauce and steak sauce are more preferable for Philly cheesesteak sandwiches. The sandwich will be delicious to eat as long as they do not become overly dry. You will be crazy but the stickiness and juicy flavors inside. 

Why do you need special sauce for Philly cheesesteak

Again, it is good to serve as a topping with a bit of garlic, black pepper, hot sauce or homemade mayo. There are some sauces like fish sauce, burger sauce that do not work well with Philly cheesesteak. Therefore, some special sauces are used to make it. 

That is why today we are going to review the 5 best sauces for Philly cheesesteak and another 4 types of sauces for serving with cheesesteak or you can use as a topping.

So what’s the delay, let’s get started.

Best sauce for Philly cheesesteak

Product NameTypeFlavorWeightPackagingOur Rating
Peter Luger Steak Sauce Steak SaucePepper, sausage12.6 fl oz (2 pack)Jar4.5/5.0
Ragu Cheesy Sauce Smooth Cheese sauceDouble Cheddar16oz Jar (Pack of 4)Jar4.7/5.0
Tallarico’s “Philly Style” Steak Sandwich SaucePhilly CheesesteakPepper, sausage14oz Jar (Pack of 2)Jar4.5/5.0
Le Sauce Gourmet Classic Green Peppercorn Finishing SauceGreen pepperPepper9 ounces(2 packs)Jar4.5/5.0
St. Elmo Steak House Gift BoxHorseradish – comboSteak, Creamy Horseradish, Cocktail, Seasoning5 Pounds
Box4.9/5.0

Steak sauce

Peter Luger Steak Sauce12.6 fl oz (2 pack)

Whey, milk, canola oil, whey protein concentrate, milk protein concentrate, contains less than 2% of salt, modified food starch, lactic acid, sodium alginate, sorbic acid as a preservative, paprika, sodium phosphate, potassium phosphate, and annatto extract (color), milkfat, cheese culture, natural flavor, enzymes.

We have picked Peter Luger steak sauce to review as one of the best sauces for Philly cheesesteak. Therefore, Peter Luger is presenting a versatile Steak Sauce which is perfectly balanced to pair with Philly cheesesteak. It comes with a combination of traditional steak sauce with a kick of horseradish. They both will give you a cocktail sauce taste.

Whatever you eat, it has to be made of essential nutrients which take part in keeping health sound. If you look at the steak sauce-making ingredients, no harsh chemical elements are not used as well as it is fat-free.

The main ingredient is whey, which is a good source of quality protein. This sauce contains milk which is a great source of calcium, vitamin D, maintains bone density, and prevents osteoporosis. Also, the canola oil has vitamins E and K and causes no harm or allergic problems like some oil.

In addition, the sauce has sorbic acid as a preservative rather than a chemical one. Sorbic acid is an organic preservative and prevents food from yeast and mold spoilage. Your favorite steak sauce will last and remain fresh for a long time. And the salt amount is less than 2% so that will not cause increase of blood pressure.

The mixture of tomato puree, crushed orange puree, vinegar, salt, onion, garlic creates the sweet, sour, and salty flavor which will enhance the taste of Philly cheesesteak surely. The sauce bottle is resealable and helps lock the exact flavor till the last drop.

If you are looking for a steak sauce to make Philly cheesesteak more delicious, Peter Luger steak sauce can be a good option for you!

  • Can enhance the taste of Philly cheesesteak
  • The perfect combination of Spicy, sweet, and sour flavor
  • Contains lots of nutrients and no harmful ingredients
  • Preserved by sorbic acid for natural and organic preservation
  • Versatile steak sauce can serve with any kind of dishes
  • Resealable bottle lid can keep the flavor lock
  • You should keep it in the refrigerator before and after opening the bottle

Smooth Cheese sauce

Ragu Cheesy Sauce 16oz Jar (Pack of 4) (Double Cheddar)

Water, yellow cheddar cheese blend [cheddar cheese butter, water, whey (milk), enzyme-modified egg yolk, whey, salt, grated parmesan cheese, grated romano disodium phosphate, natural flavor, nonfat milk, salt, annatto (color) soybean oil, white cheddar cheese blend, modified corn starch, xanthan gum, natural flavors (soy), yeast extract, paprika and annatto extractives (color)

To make the authentic cheesesteak, the main ingredients are thinly sliced boneless ribeye steaks, cheese, and caramelized onion slices. The recipe is super easy and you will enhance the taste and beauty by using Ragu Cheese Sauce. The double cheddar flavor will blow your mind.

The texture is super creamy and not too watery like many cheesy sauces. You should shake before use to get the exact consistency. 

The main ingredient is a cheddar cheese blend that has a natural aroma and nutrient value like calcium, fat, and protein, and so on. Also contains grated parmesan cheese. Both of them make an illusion with the rest of the ingredients and result in creamy, even consistency cheese sauce.

You can use the cheesy sauce as the main ingredient as well as for garnish purposes. That will eventually increase the taste and flavor of Philly cheesesteak sandwiches.

Again, cornstarch and whey also have nutrient value. There are no chemical ingredients, artificial color, or preservatives are used. The color, flavor, and preservative all are natural.

You will get a super yummy taste and organic natural ingredients in one jar! What else do you need to increase the taste of any food?

The sauce comes in durable jar packaging, and the lid is resealable. You can easily open up the jar, and a non-vented lid can lock the flavor and aroma the same as always. 

  • Give you the authentic and premier taste of Philly cheesesteak sandwich
  • Bold flavor note, rich with double cheddar
  • Grated parmesan cheese, corn starch make more consistent and creamy
  • Natural ingredients and preservatives are used
  • Stay fresh and flavorful at room temperature
  • Durable jar packaging with a resealable jar cover
  • This sauce contains grated romano cheese which is pasteurized part-skim cow’s milk, it may cause an allergic effect if you have an allergic problem due to cow milk.

Special Philly cheesesteak sauce

Tallarico’s “Philly Style” Steak Sandwich Sauce 2 Jars

Tallarico's "Philly Style" Steak Sandwich Sauce 2 Jars

Tomato paste, ground tomatoes steak sauce, soybean oil, apple cider vinegar, sherry wine, seasoning, sugar, salt, romano cheese dehydrated onions, spices, spice extractives, garlic powder,

Now we are introducing an amazing sauce that is specially made for Philly cheese steak sandwiches. If you are tired of eating ordinary cheesesteak and you want to make an authentic Philly cheesesteak sandwich, Tallarico’s can be a good choice for you.

This sauce contains tomato paste and ground tomatoes that have so many health benefits. Tomato is a good source of antioxidants as well as keeping your skin healthy.

If you like a thick and gravy mixture of cheesesteak, you should use tomato-based sauces. Tomato sauce creates a thick consistency and after baking, it remains juicy inside of the sandwich. Similarly, romano cheese is also responsible for creating thickness and sticky texture with other ingredients.

The flavor of Pepper and sausage add extra taste and aroma to the Philly cheesesteak sandwich. Also, you don’t have to use seasoning, this sauce contains a perfect seasoning of sugar and salt as well. You can use it for mixing ingredients or as a serving sauce.

Tallarico’s “Philly Style” Steak Sandwich Sauce will reduce your hassle to find out the perfect sauce for your favorite Philly cheesesteak. It is rich with a refreshing and powerful delicious taste, this mouthwatering Philly Style” Steak Sandwich Sauce can delight and brighten your plate.

  • Perfect sauce and specially made for Philly cheesesteak sandwich
  • Has a nice texture of tomato, romano cheese, and seasoning
  • The garlic powder and seasoning of salt and sugar reduce the hassle of adding extra seasonings
  • Ingredients can create a juicy and thick consistency
  • Can use for both toppings or making purposes
  • Free from fat, chemical dyes/color, and harmful preservatives

This is not suitable for all kinds of food items as it especially goes with Philly cheesesteak sandwiches

Green pepper

Le Sauce Gourmet Classic Green Peppercorn Finishing Sauce (2-Pack)

Le Sauce Gourmet Classic Green Peppercorn Finishing Sauce (2-Pack)

Heavy cream, water, mustard, distilled vinegar, water, #1-grade mustard seed, salt, mirepoix (made of carrot, celery, and onion stocks), utter, chardonnay wine, citric acid, tartaric acid, spices, and turmeric, shallots, red wine, tomato paste, gelatin, salt, carrot stock, celery stock), roasted onion, cognac, green peppercorns, granulated garlic, brown stock(veal stock(veal bones, water), beef stock, non-modified corn starch, pure cane sugar, sea salt, lactic acid

This Le Sauce Gourmet Classic Green Peppercorn is for those who like more spice flavor in Philly cheesesteak. The ultimate combination of cream, garlic, butter, green peppercorn will increase the taste of any food item either steak or fillet, pork chops, or even vegetables.

The producing ingredients heavy cream and water mustard create a suspension that is responsible for the even consistency of the sauce. When you use it as an ingredient or topping on the Philly cheesesteak that will add extra flavor to it and be able to blow your mind at every bite.

Again there is no artificial color or die in it, the other ingredients are also safe for our health.

There are 2 convenient packs and they come in a jar packaging. Each has 9 ounces of sauce that compact size will also complement your countertop.

The lid is resealable and easy to open up. The resealable bottle lid locks the real flavor of the sauce and keeps it fresh for a long time.

Eventually, this is one of the affordable sauces to delight any kind of food items along with Philly cheesesteak.  

  • Versatile and perfect sauce for spice lover
  • Make your Philly cheesesteak more spice and delicious
  • Great combination of green peppercorn, garlic, butter, water mustard
  • Consistent and smooth texture
  • Can be used as the raw ingredients as well as toppings
  • Reasonable price range comparing quality and quantity

If you are spice sensitive, green peppercorn may cause soreness of the tongue

Horseradish – Combo Philly Cheesesteak sauce

St. Elmo Steak House Gift Box (Steak Sauce, Creamy Horseradish, Cocktail Sauce, Seasoning)

It contains 4 types of sauces as Creamy Horseradish, steak sauce, cocktail sauce, and seasoning!

You can use various sauces to make a delicious Philly cheesesteak sandwich. Some of us like my younger sister like to use 3-4 types of sauces combo in Philly cheesesteak as ingredients and toppings. That will make it more flavorful and the aroma will amaze you. This combo sauce set is specially made to transform your everyday food items into more delicious ones. 

First, we are going to talk about steak sauce. You can use this one for any type of steak like ribeye steak, T-steak, and so on along with Philly cheesesteak. The steak sauce is bold, spicy, and rich with butter, orange zest, and brandy.

Not only steak, but you can also use it as a topping on wings, burgers, pizza, etc, and make the taste mouth-watering.

Creamy Horseradish – who doesn’t like Creamy Horseradish? Horseradish is an amazing sauce by itself and it has a lot of health benefits also. It is also known as “Slammer Sauce”, the savory flavor and taste of horseradish make a great environment with Philly cheesesteak.

You can use it as raw ingredients with any kinds of steaks, burgers, or even with sandwiches. Horseradish has natural antioxidants as well as boosts blood circulation.

In addition, the best part is there is no artificial color, ingredients, or preservation in it. For preservation, sorbic acid is used as a natural preservative.

Cocktail sauce – The package contains a SIGNATURE cocktail sauce which is good not only for Philly cheesesteak but also for plates of seafood like shrimp, lobster, etc. Cocktail sauces are bold and rich, that are balanced by the hints of lemon and tomato paste.

The cocktail sauce of the St. Elmo Steak House Gift Box can increase the taste and flavor of a simple food item.

The last one is seasoning, seasoning is a crucial ingredient to make salad dressing as well as one of the main ingredients to season any type of steak.

Simply rubbing on the steak and the flavor of paprika and hint of sweetness creates a delighted, mouthwatering taste in a moment. Also using seasoning can prevent the Philly cheesesteak from being over salty.

Now decide which one is your favorite?

When you can’t decide about a gift item, you can go for them. The packaging is also so nice and it’s a perfect gift item for those who like to cook with various types of sauces.

  • 4 in 1 – a perfect gift for a cook as well as a food lover
  • Steak Sauce, Creamy Horseradish, Cocktail Sauce, Seasoning in one box
  • Suitable and complement any types of food items
  • Smooth and creamy consistency
  • Can use a main ingredients and toppings both
  • Each bottle has a resealable lid and remains fresh till the last drop
  • Affordable price range comparing the quantity, quality, and packaging
  • Free from fat, artificial color, or harmful chemicals
  • The sauces should not be kept at room temperature for more than 7-10 days. You should store it in the refrigerator to keep it fresh and spiciness

What sauce do you eat with Philly Cheesesteak?

Besides these sauces, tomato sauce, mushroom, garlic sauce, even mayonnaise can serve with a Philly cheesesteak sandwich or to garnish, use as topping on the Philly cheesesteak-

For these, you can look below. We are just writing down the name as you can eat these sauces, used for topping or garnish purposes. These sauces are best in quality, they are natural and free from chemical color or preservative. Tasty and health concerns can both be fulfilled by these sauces.

Here are the sauces below-

Heinz 57 Sauce ( Tomato sauce)

Heinz 57 Sauce (10 oz Bottles, Pack of 12)
AttributeProperty
IngredientsTomato puree, high fructose corn syrup, distilled white vinegar, malt vinegar, salt, contains less than 2% of the following: modified food starch, raisin juice concentrate, sodium benzoate and potassium sorbate (preservatives), mustard flour, soybean oil, turmeric, spices, apple puree, caramel color, garlic powder, onion powder, natural flavors
FlavorTangy
Package InformationBottle
Weight10 Ounces
Rating4.7/ 5.0

Giorgio Dawn Fresh Mushroom Steak Sauce (creamy mushroom sauce)

AttributeProperty
FlavorMushroom
Package InformationCan
Weight5.4 Ounces
Rating4.9/ 5.0

A1 Sweet Chili Garlic Sauce (garlic topping)

A1 Sweet Chili Garlic Sauce 10 Oz (Pack of 4)
AttributeProperty
IngredientsTomato puree (water, tomato paste), high fructose corn syrup, vinegar, corn syrup, salt, cayenne pepper, sugar, contains less than 2% of red bell peppers, dried garlic, caramel color, xanthan gum, natural flavor, raisin paste, modified cornstarch, garlic, chili peppers, crushed orange puree, spices (contains celery), dried onions
FlavorGarlic
Package InformationBottle
Package Weight2.23 Kilograms
Rating4.8/ 5.0

Blue Plate Real Mayonnaise (mayonnaise)

Blue Plate Real Mayonnaise, 16 Ounce Jar (Pack of 12)
AttributeProperty
FlavorRegular
Package InformationJar
Package Weight5.57 Kilograms
Rating4.7/ 5.0

Final words

We try to sum up the suitable and best sauces for making delicious Philly cheesesteak sandwiches. Now it’s time to wrap up. We have chosen the best one for you according to the quality, affordability, flavor, and longevity.

And they all are made with natural ingredients as well as for preservation they use natural preservatives. Health and taste both are our main priorities before reviewing any products.

We recommend purchasing the combo sauce pack if you like cocktails and h sauces. Besides, reviewed other sauces are also suitable for making perfect and juicy Philly steak sauce as raw ingredients.

In addition, the last 4 sauces are good for using as a topping or serving with the sandwich. Make a perfect Philly cheesesteak sandwich and be a reason for the sweet smile of your beloved ones!

Let us know which one is your favorite! Also, feel free to comment below or simply inbox us to ask any questions or give suggestions. 

Stay safe, healthy and keep smiling.

Leave a Comment