As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchasesThe Philly cheesesteak is a delicious sandwich known for its savory steak, bread, caramelized onion, and cheese sauce blend. However, the sauce used is what sets it apart from other sandwiches. To figure out which sauce goes best with a Philly cheesesteak, you can choose from cheese sauce, steak sauce, tomato sauce, or even cocktail sauce. Mixing different sauces can create a unique flavor profile that enhances the sandwich’s taste, juiciness, and overall experience.
When picking a sauce, it’s essential to think about the taste and texture of the steak to create an outstanding balance of flavors. By selecting the proper sauce, a Philly cheesesteak can become an enjoyable snack.
In this article, you’ll find the best sauce for a Philly cheesesteak and the pros and cons of using a different sauce. Let’s get going.
Product Name | Product Image | Flavor | Weight | Rating |
Peter Luger Steak Sauce |  | Pepper, sausage | 12.6 fl oz (2 pack) | |
Ragu Cheesy Sauce |  | Double Cheddar | 16oz Jar (Pack of 4) | |
Tallarico's "Philly Style" Steak Sandwich Sauce |  | Pepper, sausage | 14oz Jar (Pack of 2) | |
Le Sauce Gourmet Classic Green Peppercorn Finishing Sauce |  | Pepper | 9 ounces(2 packs) | |
St. Elmo Steak House Gift Box |  | Steak, Creamy Horseradish, Cocktail, Seasoning | 5 Pounds | |
Heinz 57 Sauce |  | Tomato | 20 oz | |
Giorgio Dawn Fresh Mushroom Steak Sauce |  | Creamy mushroom | 5.4 Ounces | |
A1 Sweet Chili Garlic Sauce |  | Garlic | 2.23 Kilograms | |
Blue Plate Real Mayonnaise |  | Mayonnaise | 30 oz |
Why Do You Need Special Sauce for a Philly Cheesesteak?
The Philly cheesesteak originated in Philadelphia and was created by Pat and Harry Olivieri. This sandwich consists of ground or thinly sliced ribeye steak, caramelized onions, and melty cheese inside a long hoagie roll. Although it only takes 2–4 minutes to prepare, not all sauces work well as ingredients.
While it is possible to use a variety of sauces, such as cheese sauce or steak sauce, for a Philly cheesesteak, some sauces work better than others. The sandwich should remain dry to keep its delicious stickiness and juicy flavors inside.
As a topping, you can add garlic, black pepper, hot sauce, or homemade mayo to enhance the taste. However, certain sauces, like fish and burger sauce, do not complement a Philly cheesesteak. This is why special sauces are often used to create this iconic sandwich.
Experimentation has shown that a combination of spices like cheese and steak sauce is preferable. So, the next time you crave a Philly cheesesteak, use the right sauce to make it extra memorable.
Steak Sauce
Peter Luger Steak Sauce12.6 fl oz (2 pack)
Whey, milk, canola oil, whey protein concentrate, and milk protein concentrate all have less than 2% of the following: salt, modified food starch, lactic acid, sodium alginate, sorbic acid as a preservative, paprika, sodium phosphate, potassium phosphate, and annatto extract (color), milkfat, cheese culture, natural flavor, and enzymes.
Peter Luger Steak Sauce is a delicious condiment that can be used in a variety of ways, including as a topping for a Philly cheesesteak or as a salad dressing. When used on a Philly cheesesteak, the sauce adds a rich, tangy flavor that complements the savory flavors of the steak, caramelized onions, and melted cheese sauce.
The sauce is versatile and can be applied differently depending on your preferences. Some people like to drizzle it over the cheesesteak, while others prefer mixing it in with the steak and onions before adding the cheese sauce. Regardless of how you use it, the sauce adds a depth of flavor that takes the cheesesteak to the next level.
One of the great things about using Peter Luger Steak Sauce on a Philly cheesesteak is its thick and smooth consistency. The sauce clings well to the steak and does not run or drip off, ensuring that each bite is packed with flavor.
Another benefit of using Peter Luger Steak Sauce on a Philly cheesesteak is the quality of the ingredients. The sauce is made with all-natural ingredients and is free from artificial preservatives, colors, and flavors. This ensures that the sauce is not only delicious but also healthy.
- Can enhance the taste of Philly cheesesteak
- The perfect combination of spicy, sweet, and sour flavor
- It contains lots of nutrients and no harmful ingredients
- Preserved by sorbic acid for natural and organic preservation
- Versatile steak sauce can serve with any kind of dishes
- A resealable bottle lid can keep the flavor locked in.
- It would help to keep it in the refrigerator before and after opening the bottle.
Smooth Cheese Sauce
Ragu Cheesy Sauce 16oz Jar (Pack of 4) (Double Cheddar)
Water, yellow cheddar cheese blend [cheddar cheese, butter, water, whey (milk), enzyme-modified egg yolk, whey, salt, grated parmesan cheese, grated romano disodium phosphate, natural flavor, nonfat milk, salt, annatto (color)] soybean oil, white cheddar cheese blend, modified corn starch, xanthan gum, natural flavors (soy), yeast extract, paprika and annatto extractives (color).
The main ingredients to make an authentic cheesesteak are thinly sliced boneless ribeye steaks, cheese, and caramelized onion slices. The recipe is super easy and enhances the taste and beauty of Ragu Cheese Sauce. The flavor of double cheddar is impressive.
Like many cheesy sauces, the texture is super creamy and not too watery. Shake before using to achieve the desired consistency.
The main ingredient is a cheddar cheese blend with a natural aroma and nutrient values like calcium, fat, and protein. It also contains grated parmesan cheese. Together with the rest of the ingredients, they make it look like the cheese sauce is smooth and creamy. Plus, the color, flavor, and preservative are all natural.
You can use the cheese sauce as a main ingredient for garnish purposes. That will eventually increase the taste and flavor of Philly cheesesteak sandwiches. Delicious taste, organic and natural ingredients are found in one jar.
The sauce comes in durable jar packaging, and the lid is resealable. You can easily open the jar; a non-vented lid keeps the flavor and aroma the same.
- It gives the authentic and premier taste of a Philly cheesesteak
- Bold flavor note, rich with double cheddar
- Grated parmesan cheese makes a more consistent and creamy flavor
- Natural ingredients and preservatives are used
- Stay fresh and flavorful at room temperature
- Durable jar packaging with a resealable jar cover
- This sauce has grated Romano cheese made from pasteurized part-skim cow’s milk which is not recommended for someone allergic to cow’s milk.
Special Philly Cheesesteak Sauce
Tallarico’s “Philly Style” Steak Sandwich Sauce | 2 Jars
Tomato paste, tomato sauce, ground tomatoes, steak sauce, soybean oil, apple cider vinegar, sherry wine, seasoning, sugar, salt, provolone cheese sauce, dehydrated onions, spices, spice extractives, and garlic powder.
Introducing Tallarico’s “Philly Style” Steak Sandwich Sauce – a fantastic option for those looking for an authentic Philly cheesesteak experience. This cheese sauce contains tomato paste and ground tomatoes, which are a good source of antioxidants and help keep your skin healthy.
This tomato-based sauce is perfect for a thick, gravy-like cheesesteak mixture that balances well with caramelized onion. Its thick consistency makes the sandwich juicy even after baking. The provolone cheese sauce is added to create a thick, sticky texture.
With the pepper and sausage added to this sauce, your Philly cheesesteak will taste and smell better without extra seasoning. The sauce contains the perfect balance of sugar and salt, and it can be used for mixing ingredients or as a serving sauce.
Tallarico’s “Philly Style” Steak Sandwich Sauce is the perfect hassle-free cheese sauce for those looking for the perfect cheese sauce for their favorite Philly cheesesteak. This mouthwatering cheese sauce is bursting with flavor and will please the taste buds.
- Perfect sauce and specially made for a Philly cheesesteak
- It has a nice texture of tomato, romano cheese, and seasoning
- The garlic powder and seasoning of salt and sugar reduce the hassle of adding extra seasonings
- Ingredients can create a juicy and thick consistency
- Can use for both toppings or making purposes
- Free from fat, chemical dyes/color, and harmful preservatives
This is only suitable for some food items, especially Philly cheesesteak sandwiches.
Green Pepper
Le Sauce Gourmet Classic Green Peppercorn Finishing Sauce (2-Pack)
Heavy cream, water, mustard, distilled vinegar, water, #1-grade mustard seed, salt, mirepoix (made of carrot, celery, and onion stocks), butter, chardonnay wine, citric acid, tartaric acid, spices, and turmeric, shallots, red wine, tomato paste, gelatin, salt, carrot stock, celery stock), roasted onion, cognac, green peppercorns, granulated garlic, brown stock(veal stock(veal bones, water), beef stock, non-modified corn starch, pure cane sugar, sea salt, lactic acid
Le Sauce Gourmet Classic Green Peppercorn is an excellent choice for those who enjoy a spicy flavor in their Philly cheesesteak. The combination of cream, garlic, butter, and green peppercorns will enhance the taste of any food, including steak, pork chops, fillets, or vegetables.
The sauce’s smooth texture comes from the use of heavy cream and water mustard, which creates a suspension. Whether used as an ingredient or topping on a Philly cheesesteak, it adds extra flavor to every bite.
This sauce is made with natural ingredients and contains no artificial colors or dyes, ensuring it is safe for our health. The two-pack comes in jar packaging, with each jar containing 9 ounces of sauce. The compact size makes it easy to store on your countertop.
The lid is easy to open and close, keeping the sauce fresh for a long time and preserving its natural flavor. This affordable sauce will surely please any food item, especially your Philly cheesesteak.
- Versatile and perfect sauce for spice lovers
- Make your Philly cheesesteak spicy and delicious.
- Great combination of green peppercorn, garlic, butter, water mustard
- Consistent and smooth texture
- It can be used as the raw ingredients as well as toppings
- Reasonable price range comparing quality and quantity
Green peppercorns may cause tongue soreness if you are sensitive to spices.
Horseradish – Combo Philly Cheesesteak Sauce
St. Elmo Steak House Gift Box (Steak Sauce, Creamy Horseradish, Cocktail Sauce, Seasoning)
Water, soybean oil, horseradish, sugar, champagne vinegar, food starch, distilled vinegar, egg yolks, salt, mustard flour, molasses, corn syrup, caramel color, garlic powder, tamarind, natural flavor, spices, sorbic acid, vitamin E, and xanthan gum. It contains four sauces: creamy horseradish, steak sauce, cocktail sauce, and seasoning.
The Tallarico’s “Elmo Steak House Gift Box” offers the perfect set of sauces to add a burst of flavor to the Philly cheesesteak sandwich. This combo sauce set is specially crafted to transform everyday food items into delicious ones.
The steak sauce is bold, spicy, and rich, with butter, orange zest, and brandy. It can be used for any type of steak, from ribeye to T-bone. The creamed horseradish sauce has a savory flavor that combines perfectly with the Philly cheesesteak, and it can also be used in burgers, sandwiches, and other dishes. Horseradish has natural antioxidants that boost blood circulation.
The cocktail sauce in the gift box is perfect for seafood and Philly cheesesteak, with a rich and robust flavor balanced with hints of lemon and tomato paste. Lastly, the seasoning is made from paprika and a hint of sweetness, creating a mouthwatering taste for any dish.
All the sauces are made with natural ingredients, and no artificial colors, ingredients, or preservatives are added. Sorbic acid is used as a natural preservative for food preservation. Use these sauces to take your Philly cheesesteak to the next level or enhance any dish with a burst of flavor.
- 4 in 1 – a perfect gift for a cook as well as a food lover
- Steak Sauce, Creamy Horseradish, Cocktail Sauce, and seasoning in one box
- Suitable and complement any type of food items
- Smooth and creamy consistency
- You can use main ingredients and toppings both
- Each bottle has a resealable lid and remains fresh till the last drop
- Affordable price range comparing the quantity, quality, and packaging
- Free from fat, artificial color, or harmful chemicals
- The sauces should be kept at room temperature for 7–10 days. It would help if you stored it in the refrigerator to keep it fresh and spicy.
What Sauce Do You Put on a Philly Cheesesteak?
In addition to the aforementioned sauces, tomato sauce, mushroom sauce, garlic sauce, and even mayonnaise can be used as toppings or garnishes for a Philly cheesesteak sandwich. These sauces are all-natural and do not contain any added colors or preservatives. They are both delicious and healthy, satisfying both taste and health concerns. See below for the names of these sauces.
Heinz 57 Sauce ( Tomato sauce)
| Attribute | Property |
| Ingredients | Tomato puree, high fructose corn syrup, distilled white vinegar, malt vinegar, salt, contains less than 2% of the following: modified food starch, raisin juice concentrate, sodium benzoate and potassium sorbate (preservatives), mustard flour, soybean oil, turmeric, spices, apple puree, caramel color, garlic powder, onion powder, natural flavors |
| Flavor | Tangy |
| Package Information | Bottle |
| Weight | 20 Ounces |
| Rating | 4.7/ 5.0 |
Giorgio Dawn Fresh Mushroom Steak Sauce (creamy mushroom sauce)
| Attribute | Property |
| Flavor | Mushroom |
| Package Information | Can |
| Weight | 5.4 Ounces |
| Rating | 4.9/ 5.0 |
A1 Sweet Chili Garlic Sauce (garlic topping)
| AttributePropertyIngredientsTomato puree (water, tomato paste), high fructose corn syrup, vinegar, corn syrup, salt, cayenne pepper, sugar, contains less than 2% of red bell peppers, dried garlic, caramel color, xanthan gum, natural flavor, raisin paste, modified cornstarch, garlic, chili peppers, crushed orange puree, spices (contains celery), dried onions | |
| Flavor | Garlic |
| Package Information | Bottle |
| Package Weight | 2.23 Kilograms |
| Rating | 4.8/ 5.0 |
Blue Plate Real Mayonnaise (mayonnaise)
| Attribute | Property |
| Flavor | Regular |
| Package Information | Jar |
| Package Weight | 30 oz |
| Rating | 4.7/ 5.0 |
Final Words
Now it’s time to wrap up the suitable and best sauces for making delicious Philly cheesesteak sandwiches. The ones chosen above are the best according to quality, affordability, flavor, and longevity. And they are all made with natural ingredients and use natural preservatives for preservation. Health and taste are both our main priorities before reviewing any products.
If you like cocktails and hot sauces, you should purchase the combo sauce pack. Aside from the ones listed, you can also use other spices as raw ingredients to make a perfect and juicy Philly steak sauce.
Also, the last four sauces can be used to top the sandwich or be served alongside it. Make a delicious and authentic Philly cheesesteak sandwich and be the reason for your loved ones’ sweet smiles!
